She Came, She Saw, She Conquered (But Just Barely)
Photo by Shiela Whaley from video courtesy of WMC-TV, Channel 5
As they say, it aint over til its over, and theres no guaranteeing that the intra-party squabble among local Democrats is. But there is, as of Monday night, a new chairman of the Shelby County Democrats. It is State Representative Kathryn Bowers, elected by a vote of 21-20 by the 41-member party executive committee in a special meeting at the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers union hall on Madison.
Monday nights special meeting had been agreed upon by the partys two warring factons -- one supporting the now former chairman Gale Jones Carson, the other backing Bowers -- after the two rivals for the chairmanship deadlocked 20-20 at the regularly scheduled party convention on April 12th at Hamilton High School..
But the factions had disagreed seriously about an intervening event, a meeting of May 1st at which Carson, still holding office, had presided over the election of other officers, most of whom were her own partisans. (She had offered some positions to supporters of Bowers, all of whom declined in a show of factional solidarity.) Carsons contention was that party bylaws called for such an election following the convention; the Bowers faction countered that it was up to the new committee elected on April 12th to set its own schedule.
In any case, the work of May 1st was undone Monday night with the election of Bowers -- whose support came principally from the partys residual Ford and Farris factions, from her fellow legislators and their allies on the committee, and from the new committees white minority. Carson, who serves as Memphis Mayor Willie Herentons press secretary, had strong support from the mayors wing of the party. (Herenton himself had put in an appearance on Carsons behalf at the partys pre-convention March caucus at Hamilton.)
A slate of new officers, composed overwhelmingly of Bowers supporters, was also elected as the election of the Carson-approved slate on May 1st was formally rescinded.
Among the highlights (or lowlights) of the evening:
As soon as the vote totals were announced, Carson offered perfunctory congratulations to Bowers, then stepped down from her presiding seat on the platform of the IBEW hall. As Bowers began to officiate in her role as newly elected chairman, a Carson delegate moved to adjourn the meeting and was seconded. But then, before a vote could be taken on the motion, most members of the Carson faction -- notably including the now-former chairman herself -- began to exit the building, thereby abandoning any chance of a favorable vote for adjournment.
At one point, Shelby County Commissioner Deidre Malone, an observer and close friend of Carsons, busied herself trying to finger for the media a committee member -- and Bowers supporter -- named Renita Scott-Pickens. Pickens, it seemed, was a county jailer who had taken off from work so as to be on hand to cast her vote. Asked about that, Pickens answered mysteriously that she had a legal action pending against the sheriffs department and would refer questions to my lawyer.
At another point, police officer Robert Gill, one of the diehard Carson remnant who stayed behind to contest various issues (or to agitate, as Bowers would term it) raised one of his several objections to a procedure under way, and the new chairman directed her newly appointed parliamentarian, Del Gill, to adjudicate the issue. Unsurprisingly, the parliamentarian ruled decisively against the officer, who happened to be his brother.
Committee member Marianne Wolff issued two apologies -- one public and one private. To the assembly at large, Wolff said, I really feel I caused a lot of this by being sick. Wolffs illness at the party convention of April 12th had caused her to leave early and prevented her tie-breaking vote on Bowers behalf. And to a reporter she attempted to explain away her attempts to misrepresent to the media the spelling of her name and her address this way:: I said I lived in Germantown and I spelled my name with one Ôf,; said Wolff of Cordova, adding with an exotic ex post facto logic, I thought you would know better if I put it that way.
Committee member Janie Orr, nominated at one point for the position of assistant treasurer, declined, saying forthrightly, Id be a disaster doing anything with money! The nominating process had included several such moments over the past several weeks. At the May 1st meeting, when it was the Bowers factions time to obfuscate, committee member Darrell Catron, one of the state representatives supporters, had ducked out of the meeting long enough to pull himself a Diet Coke and returned to hear what he thought was an attempt to nominate him for an office. I decline! he shouted, to general amusement, as his name had not in fact been mentioned.
On Monday night, Carson supporter Malcolm Nelson, who had earlier lambasted Bowers backer David Cocke for moving to disapprove the minutes of May 1st (Cockes point being to nullify that meetings election of the Carson slate), was nominated for an office by a Bowers supporter and was asked if he had anything to say to the committee. He rose and said gravely, Good evening, then withdrew. (Later, though, both he and another Carson diehard, Lenard Jennings, seemed uncertain as to whether they should accept such goodwill nominations. Jennings finally allowed himself to be voted on for an at-large post on the party steering committee but went down 13-12 to Jesse Jeff, his fellow Carson supporter.)
Considering that one of the bones of contention between the two factions had been Carsons insistence that party bylaws called for meetings on the first Thursday of each month (hence her decision to schedule the disputed May 1st meeting), it was ironic that Bowers supporter Dwayne Thompson moved successfully, late in Monday nights meeting, to schedule the new committees regular meetings on -- guess what? -- the first Thursday of each month.
As the Old Guard yielded to the New, there were some moments of minor pathos. Freelance journalist Bill Larsha, a committee veteran,, had been appointed by Carson as parliamentarian to succeed Del Gill at the May 1st meeting. As he took his seat on the dais before Monday nights meeting, Larsha beamed and showed off the proud possession he had armed himself with. It was a vintage, dog-eared copy of Roberts Rules of Order, the parliamentarians bible, and he pointed to a faded signature on the inner leaf of the volume.
Look, Larsha had said excitedly, this is signed by the last surviving member of the Roberts family! But when Bowers took over, her first act as new chairman was to depose Larsha, whose tenure in office therefore ended up being measured in minutes, and to rename Gill. Larsha looked forlorn as he gathered up his literary treasure and stepped off the officers platform..
At the May 1st meeting, ex-Teamster leader Sidney Chism, a close ally of both Carsons and Herentons, had held out the prospect that if Bowers people were successful in both electing her and rescinding the Carson slate of other officers elected at that meeting, then the factions might, as the succeeding months wore on, take turns voting each other out of office.
Chism, who is not a committee member, was not on hand Monday night, but another spokesperson for Carson, Norma Lester, one of the former chairmans slate, joined Bowers in an appeal to set aside such differences in the common interest of defeating Republicans. But Lesters proposed remedy -- the appointment of a five-member special committee composed of two Bowers supporters, two Carson supporters and a neutral (whoever that might be, under the highly polarized circumstances) to select a slate of new party officers -- was rejected, and the election of a Bowers-dominated slate went ahead as planned.
Upon formally taking office, Bowers had given an exhortatory speech in which she promised to establish a paty headquarters, raise $250,000 for the partys 2004 general election fund, and preside over not one group but a unified party. Likening the Shelby County Democratic Party that she foresaw to a locomotive, Bowers urged Democrats at large to climb aboard and declaimed, Its going to be a moving train!
That remains to be seen. On Monday night, in any case, the train left the station without its full component aboard.