In keeping with a venerable tradition, local Democrats have their disagreements. Shelby County Democrats continue to conform to the hoary old characterization of the party coined by the late Will Rogers, whose stand-up act often included the line, I dont belong to an organized political party. Im a Democrat.
Some think that local party members continue to justify such a description; even their attempts at organization can often lead to greater confusion. Take recent efforts to form a Shelby County coordinating committee to collaborate with the state Democratic coordinating committee, the Nashville-based organization that will oversee the statewide campaigns of Phil Bredesen and Bob Clement, Democratic nominees for governor and the U.S. Senate, respectively.
At one point, Reginald French, a veteran associate of Memphis Mayor Willie Herentons, was tapped by the state organization to head up the local coordinating committee. But the state committee, directed by veteran Democratic operative Bob Corney, could never agree on terms with French, who divided his time during the last year between the campaigns of Bredesen and A C Wharton, the newly inaugurated Shelby County mayor,
Corney and company then settled on the expedient of asking five recent chairpersons of the Shelby County Democratic Party to serve as co-chairs of the local committee. These were Gale Jones Carson, the current chair, and four of her predecessors: John Farris, Jim Strickland, Sidney Chism, and David Cocke.
That, in turn, didnt sit well with several elected officials -- especially members of the state legislative delegation, several of whom found themselves opposed in the recent state Democratic primary by candidates allegedly hand-picked or supported by Chism, a power broker in his own right.
On Monday night of last week, Corney met in Memphis with the five members of the proposed local coordinating committee. Later the same night Democratic members of the legislative delegatoin met with Bredesen, and several expressed dissatisfaction with the committees makeup. (This was one week after various local legislators and other officials had met with Clement in Memphis to express their concerns.)
State Rep. Kathryn Bowers, one of the aggrieved legislators, recalls the groups perspective this way: We didnt want the same thing happening with Bredesen and Clement that happened two years ago with Al Gore. The Democrats presidential candidate in 2000 carried Shelby County by a margin of some 50,000 -- but only, maintained Bowers, after the late involvement locally of former congressman Harold Ford Sr., now a consultant living mainly in Florida.
We just felt there wasnt enough input from elected officials on the coordinating committee, and we felt there were people on the committee that didnt hold office and might be too remote from actual voting Democrats and their concerns, said Bowers, who acknowledged that she and several other legislators were not exactly enamored of Chisms election efforts.
Accordingly, she said, the legislative group proposed to Bredesen that she, state Senator Roscoe Dixon, and state Rep. Ulysses Jones, be added to the local coordinating committee. And Bredesen, the former Nashville mayor who, as gubernatorial committee, has clout second to none with the state committee, endorsed the idea, according to Bowers.
Carson, who doubles as Mayor Herentons press secretary, said she had not been apprised of such a change and doubted its value. None of these people have approached me, she said. And what good would it do to appoint three members of the delegation to the committee and leave the others off?
As of early this week, no final resolution had been made of the issue. One member of the current committee, asking not to be identified by name, characterized the disagreement as a lot of B.S., essentially, a lot of fuss over nothing, pointing out that Corney and the state organization, in close tandem with the campaigns of Clement and Bredesen, would decide most matters.
In part, of course, the dustup is a patronage matter, since the local committee with select participants in GOTV (get-out-the-vote) efforts, and several of these will be handsomely compensated for their efforts. In part, too, it reflects continuing factionalism within the party, coinciding in some ways with the not altogether healed Herenton/Ford schism of recent years as well as newer divides in the evolving local party.
In any case, Will Rogers wouldnt have any trouble understanding it.
Carson, incidentally, did her best to put to rest a rumor that Herenton might support Clement opponent Lamar Alexander, the Republican Senate nominee with hwom the mayor has shared one or two corporate board memberships in the past. Thats somebody attempting to make mischief, she said, acknowledging that she had been asked about the rumor by party officials in Nashville.
I can say categorically that the mayor will not support Alexander. She said Herenton will be active in Bredesens campaign and has not yet determined the extent of his involvement in Clements.